Colombian Cheese Arepas with Melted Mozzarella
Colombian arepas de queso made from precooked masarepa maize flour, cheese and warm water, then pan-griddled until crisp outside and soft within.
๐ฝ๏ธ Original recipe: 4 servingsThe original quantities and written steps are for 4 servings. Changing the number scales only the ingredient checklist, not method or cooking times. Cook larger batches in appropriate pans.
Jump to ingredients ยท Jump to method

Cooking times vary with equipment and ingredient size; look for the stated texture and doneness cues.
๐ Ingredients checklist
๐ฉโ๐ณ Step-by-step method
Check the correct precooked corn flour
Measure 240 g masarepa labelled precooked arepa maize flour, not standard raw cornmeal, masa harina for tortillas or cornflour starch. Warm 300 ml drinking water to a comfortable hand-warm temperature and keep 60 ml milk nearby; the correct precooked flour hydrates without raw-grain cooking.
Mix warm liquid with salt and soft butter
In a large clean bowl combine the 300 ml lukewarm drinking water, 60 ml full-cream milk, 4 g fine salt and 15 g of the measured 35 g softened butter. Stir with a wooden spoon until salt dissolves and the butter spreads into small soft flecks, rather than remaining in a single lump.
Hydrate masarepa gradually into a soft dough
Sprinkle the measured 240 g precooked maize flour into the liquid in three additions, mixing each before adding more. Let stand around 5 minutes to absorb water, then knead with clean hands for 2โ3 minutes until the dough feels like firm modelling clay and does not stick heavily to the fingers.
Fold in both cheeses evenly
Add 80 g crumbled queso fresco and 80 g of the measured 130 g grated mozzarella into the hydrated dough, reserving 50 g mozzarella for the finish. Knead gently for about one minute until there are small cheese flecks throughout; the dough should hold when rolled into a ball.
Shape four evenly thick discs with smooth edges
Divide the dough into four equal balls. Flatten each between clean palms to approximately 12 cm across and 1.5 cm thick, then gently smooth any cracked edges with damp fingers. Keeping each disc the same thickness ensures the middle gets hot before the outside burns.
Brown arepas gently in buttered pan
Heat a broad non-stick griddle on medium-low and melt the remaining 20 g butter, spreading it thinly. Add two arepas at a time and cook about 5โ6 minutes per side until both surfaces have a golden crust and the discs feel firm enough to lift with a spatula; lower heat if butter darkens rapidly.
Melt reserved cheese on the warm cooked arepas
When all four discs are hot and cooked through, scatter the reserved 50 g mozzarella evenly over their tops. Cover the pan over low heat for about 1โ2 minutes until the cheese melts. Keep the lid from dripping condensation onto the crust; remove once the tops are glossy and warm.
Serve four warm arepas and refrigerate extras
Serve one warm arepa per person as breakfast or a snack. If any are left over, cool them promptly in shallow clean containers and refrigerate at 5ยฐC or colder; reheat on a griddle until the cheese centre is steaming hot. Masarepa is not a substitute for an ordinary wheat flour baking mix.
Helpful cooking tips and swaps
Use genuine precooked masarepa, never raw cornmeal or corn starch. Rest the hydrated dough and smooth cracked edges before pan cooking.
๐ก๏ธ Food safety and allergens
Contains milk/dairy from cheese, milk and butter. Check the masarepa label for declared cross-contact with wheat/gluten.
Cool promptly, refrigerate cheese arepas at 5ยฐC or below, use within 2โ3 days or freeze promptly. Reheat until the centre is hot.
Practical FAQs
Can I make a bigger batch?
Yes. Use the ingredient scaler but adjust the number of pans or batches. Cooking time does not automatically scale with quantity.
How should leftovers be stored?
Cool promptly, refrigerate cheese arepas at 5ยฐC or below, use within 2โ3 days or freeze promptly. Reheat until the centre is hot.
Food safety source: Food Standards Australia New Zealand