SMART CHOICE 365 / Smart Meals 365
🍽️ SMART MEALS 365 · Lunch & Dinner

Indian Butter Chicken Makhani

Indian-style chicken makhani: yoghurt-marinated chicken browned separately and simmered in a silky tomato, butter and cream sauce, cooked safely to 75°C.

🍽️ Original recipe: 4 servingsThe original quantities and written steps are for 4 servings. Changing the number scales only the ingredient checklist, not method or cooking times. Cook larger batches in appropriate pans.

Jump to ingredients · Jump to method

Indian Butter Chicken Makhani prepared dish

📅 Add to weekly meal plan

Prep20 min
Cook40 min
Marinate and rest40 min
Total100 min approx.
Making4 servings
DifficultyModerate

Cooking times vary with equipment and ingredient size; look for the stated texture and doneness cues.

🛒 Ingredients checklist

Original 4 servings · Enter 1–100 whole servings · Only ingredients change

👩‍🍳 Step-by-step method

  1. Keep chicken separate and prepare a yoghurt marinade

    Cut 600 g chilled boneless chicken thighs into even 3 cm cubes on a dedicated raw-meat board. In a large non-reactive bowl stir 140 g yoghurt, 20 ml lemon juice, 4 g Kashmiri chilli, 2 g turmeric, 4 g of the 7 g garam masala, 3 g of the 6 g salt, 10 g minced garlic and 10 g grated ginger.

  2. Marinate under refrigeration for 30 minutes

    Coat the chicken cubes evenly with the yoghurt-spice mixture, cover and refrigerate at 5°C or below for at least 30 minutes. Keep used utensils away from the ready-to-eat ingredients, and never rinse raw poultry under the tap because splashes can spread bacteria.

  3. Brown chicken in two batches without crowding

    Heat a heavy frying pan over medium-high heat for 2 minutes, then add half the measured 15 ml neutral oil. Lift half the marinated chicken pieces into the pan, leaving excess raw marinade in the bowl. Brown for around 3 minutes per side; move to a clean plate, and repeat with remaining oil and pieces.

  4. Melt butter with garlic and ginger

    Reduce the pan to medium-low, add 45 g unsalted butter, then stir in the remaining 10 g minced garlic and 10 g ginger for about 45 seconds. The butter should foam gently and the garlic smell sweet rather than turn bitter brown; lower the heat if the milk solids start to darken.

  5. Simmer tomato passata with spices

    Pour in 500 g tomato passata and 120 ml drinking water with the remaining 3 g garam masala and 3 g salt. Bring to a gentle bubble and simmer for 10–12 minutes, stirring regularly until the sauce coats the back of a spoon instead of running like water. Add the measured 8 g sugar only if the tomato tastes sharply acidic.

  6. Finish cooking chicken safely in the sauce

    Add the browned chicken and any juices from its clean resting plate to the simmering tomato sauce. Keep a gentle simmer for roughly 10–12 minutes, stirring and turning pieces. Check the thickest chicken cube with a clean food thermometer: it must reach at least 75°C in the centre, not merely look white outside.

  7. Finish the cream sauce without splitting it

    Reduce heat to low, then pour in 150 ml cream a little at a time, stirring steadily until orange and smooth. Crush 2 g dried fenugreek leaves between fingers and scatter in. Keep the mixture just steaming for 1–2 minutes, not boiling hard, to avoid breaking the creamy sauce.

  8. Rest briefly, serve hot and chill leftovers

    Turn off the heat and rest the covered pot for about 10 minutes so the sauce settles and no splatters remain. Spoon into four serving bowls and offer with rice or naan if desired (not included in measured ingredients). Cool leftovers promptly in shallow containers and refrigerate at 5°C or colder.

Helpful cooking tips and swaps

Brown the marinated chicken first, then cook it completely in the sauce. Keep cream at low heat and use a food thermometer to verify 75°C inside chicken.

🌡️ Food safety and allergens

Contains milk/dairy in yoghurt, butter and cream. Read spice-blend labels for other declared allergens.

Clean everything that touched raw chicken. Cool cooked chicken promptly, refrigerate at 5°C or below and eat within 2–3 days or freeze early; reheat until steaming hot throughout.

Practical FAQs

Can I make a bigger batch?

Yes. Use the ingredient scaler but adjust the number of pans or batches. Cooking time does not automatically scale with quantity.

How should leftovers be stored?

Clean everything that touched raw chicken. Cool cooked chicken promptly, refrigerate at 5°C or below and eat within 2–3 days or freeze early; reheat until steaming hot throughout.

Food safety source: Food Standards Australia New Zealand

← Browse all recipes